Skip to content
The Institute of Functional NeuroscienceThe Institute of Functional Neuroscience
  • Institute of Functional Neuroscience
  • Home
    • Why Choose IFN
    • IFN Locations
  • Discover IFN
    • About Us
    • Affiliations
    • Mission & Vision
  • Research
  • News
    • Information Sessions
    • Upcoming Information Sessions
    • News Articles
    • Dr Beck Presentations
  • Appointments
    • Book Appointments
    • What will my Therapy involve?
    • FAQs
    • IFN Locations
  • Patient Guide
    • Overview
    • Treatment Fees
    • Patient Forms
    • Case Studies
    • Information Dates & Times
    • About Dr Beck
  • Payments
  • Contact
Publications

Manipulation and Blood Pressute

Manipulation and BP.2
Manipulation of the Spine and Brain Changes
Leisman Melillo Aymmetry LD-06
Developmental Coordination Disorder

Publications

Depression & Asymmetry

Publications

Positioning Systems a Review

Publications

DC and EEG

Publications

Concussion and EEG

Publications

Complex Regional Pain Syndrome

Original Publications, Publications

Comparing Brain Activation during different types of Proprioceptive Inputs

Publications

Clinical Concepts in Functional Connectomics

Publications

Cervical Manipulation and Pupil Response

Publications

Cerebellum and Autism

Publications

Bold EEG Correlation

Publications

Vestibular and balance issues following

Publications

Blindfolded Gait Training

Publications

Autism and EEG

Publications

Vestibular Rehabilatation

Publications

Autism and Asymmetry

Publications

Umbrella Approach To DCD pdf

Publications

Attention and Brain Function

Publications

Asymmetry in Stress

Publications

Asymmetry and Autonomic Function

Publications

Asymmetry and Alzheimers

Publications

Asymmetry and ADHD

Publications

ADHD and Asymmetry

Publications

Activity in the Contralateral Motor Cortex

Publications

Abnormal Cortical Asymmetry

Publications

Repeatative Steps Training In Parkinsons

Publications

Normal Development of Brain Circuits

Publications

Neuroplasticity by integration

Publications

Neuroplastcity in Children pdf

Publications

Neuromodulation Following

Publications

Milti-watt near-infrared light therapy as a neuroregenerative treatment for traumatic brain injury

Publications

Music and Cognitive Abilities

Publications

Motor Rehabilitation Overlapped by Brain Stimulation

Publications

Motor Training and Cortical Plasticity

Publications

Modulation of the brain in Rehabilitation

Publications

Modulation of the brain in rehabilitation

Publications

Merzenich Somatosensory

Publications

Manipulation of the Spine and Brain Changes

Publications

Leisman Melillo Aymmetry LD-06

Publications

Laser & Dementia

Publications

Interhemispheric Competition Following Stroke

Publications

Identification and Correction of Asymmetric Cortical Function

Original Publications, Publications

Harnessing Neuroplasticity for Clinical Applications

Publications

Gut to Brain Connection

Publications

Glucose Uptake by Neurons

Publications

Functional Connectivity in DCD

Publications

Functional Connection Disorders in Developmental Coordination Disorder

Publications

Functional Anatomy of Movement

Publications

Forehead Skin Temperature and Brain Disease

Publications

Emotion and EEG

Publications

EEG and Anxiety

Publications

ABOUT


The Institute of Functional Neuroscience was founded in Australia in 2008 to inspire hope and enhance humanity through clinical advances in neuroplasticity.

CONTACT


Head Office
Western Australia:

88 Catalano Circuit,
Canning Vale, 6155
Western Australia

Phone: (08) 6254 2282
Email: [email protected]

LOCATIONS


Perth
Sydney
Hong Kong
China
Ontario

FACEBOOK


Institute of Functional Neuroscience

4 weeks ago

Institute of Functional Neuroscience

The Fantastical Claims of Consumer Brain Stimulation Wearable Devices. Really?

The business of wearable brain measurement and stimulus devices promising benefits that range from improved mood to the betterment of age-related decline, is booming.
The digital brain health market, which includes wearable brain devices, is likely to grow to $6 billion by 2020. Technology companies already are marketing brain recording and stimulating devices directly to consumers. Are these companies adequately—and ethically— educating consumers about both their benefits and the risks involved?

Given this technology’s intimate relationship with the brain, a number of ethical questions must be addressed so that the technology can achieve the goal of contributing to human performance. Topics that must be considered before using one of these devices include; safety, privacy, authenticity, and oversight.

A recent paper published in the scientific journal Neuron counted 41 direct to consumer wearable neurodevices on the market of which 22 are EEG recording devices and 19 are direct stimulation devices claiming to do various different things from relieving stress, enhancing mood and improving sleep to increasing concentration, improving productivity, enhancing memory and enhancing physical performance. Really?

Most of the claims were based on references to general scientific papers not specific to the device and in some cases, even entirely irrelevant to the claims being made.
Where’s the evidence?

The authors attempted to find the research referenced by these companies that supported their claims. Out of the 41 devices they found links to research for 33 of these devices but only 8 referenced studies specific to the device. The rest had references to general scientific papers not specific to the device and in some cases, even entirely irrelevant to the claims being made. So what is the evidence for these broad claims? Are they supported in the scientific literature?

Here are some major issues that have not yet been answered:

Quality of the signal
The first concern of whether they can actually record sufficiently good quality data to make any sense of it at all. Consumer devices such as Muse, Neurosky and pretty much all the others, use dry electrodes which have notoriously bad contact quality, and therefore impedance values, which influence the quality of the signal, fluctuate wildly. With no real studies demonstrating the quality of their signals by comparison to gel based systems, it is pretty safe to assume they are poor quality EEG signals. These receptors are simply not good enough to make accurate estimates of EEG features in real time for any individual.

Individual Variability
Another challenge is individual variability. People have their own unique profiles that differ from one another and also fluctuate over time. This is one of the reasons population level data is so difficult to translate into predictions at the individual level. It is also one of the reasons there are so many inconsistencies in the literature and contradictory studies and why only experienced clinicians should determine treatment protocols for the application of these modalities.

Consumer brain recording and stimulant technologies make all sorts of claims that are simply not substantiated in the literature at the level of individual effects.
So, taking into account poor signal quality, added to weak correlations between individual EEG features and any particular state, what you get out of it as a user is essentially “junk”. The really big concern with these devises is that the “junk” may not be harmless.

“We know that these technologies have the power to affect our brain, in some cases very profound changes can occur. We just don’t know to what degree and in what areas they are affecting our brains, or what degree of damage might they bring about in the short or long term?” stated Dr Randy Beck, Director of the Institute of Functional Neuroscience, an expert in the application and clinical effects of the stimulus modalities that many of these devices claim use to change your brain.

Dr Beck expressed caution when using these devices until a deeper understanding of their effects are understood. “In the clinic, we have protocols that control how many sessions, the duration, and the intensity of these methods and we monitor the effects of the stimulation very closely. But when you leave it to consumers that usually have no training or understanding of neuroscience to make those decisions, it’s really difficult to know, or even anticipate, what harms they could be doing to themselves.”

Who’s minding the space?
There are few regulations or oversight when it comes to wearable brain devices. Most devices don’t have, and are not required to have, U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval to go to market In fact, in 2016 the FDA issued a guidance that it would not enforce regulations for low risk devices marketed for general cognitive enhancement or wellness purposes. So consumers must trust the very companies who develop and market these products to explain both the potential benefits and risks of their use.

References
Owning Ethical Innovation: Claims about Commercial Wearable Brain Technologies, Iris Coates McCall, Chloe Lau,Nicole Minielly, and Judy Illes, Neuron May 22, 2019
Mind-Reading or Misleading? Assessing Direct-to-Consumer Electroencephalography (EEG) Devices Marketed for Wellness and Their Ethical and Regulatory Implications, Anna Wexler & Robert Thibault J Cognitive Enhancement August 2018 … See MoreSee Less

Photo

View on Facebook

·Share

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Linked InShare by Email

Institute of Functional Neuroscience

1 month ago

Institute of Functional Neuroscience

IFN and HorsePower Australia are excited to announce our Melbourne Cup Day Thank You Promotion! … See MoreSee Less

Photo

View on Facebook

·Share

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Linked InShare by Email

Institute of Functional Neuroscience

2 months ago

Institute of Functional Neuroscience

www.youtube.com/watch?v=wsyErtZ0SJI&t=154s … See MoreSee Less

Holly Bridges Podcast : Breakthroughs in Autism SE01 EP04

www.youtube.com

Holly Bridges, author of ‘Reframe Your Thinking Around Autism’ hosts the second of a two part podcast with leaders at the forefront of new and thrilling auti…

Video

View on Facebook

·Share

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Linked InShare by Email

Inspiring Hope, Creating Expertise and Enhancing Humanity
Copyright 2019 © Institute of Functional Neuroscience
Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | Site Map
  • Button
  • Button
  • Home
    • Why Choose IFN
    • IFN Locations
  • Discover IFN
    • About Us
    • Affiliations
    • Mission & Vision
  • Research
  • News
    • Information Sessions
    • Upcoming Information Sessions
    • News Articles
    • Dr Beck Presentations
  • Appointments
    • Book Appointments
    • What will my Therapy involve?
    • FAQs
    • IFN Locations
  • Patient Guide
    • Overview
    • Treatment Fees
    • Patient Forms
    • Case Studies
    • Information Dates & Times
    • About Dr Beck
  • Payments
  • Contact